Donate

252. Born to Belong: Grieving What Should Have Been There From the Start

What if the loss you're carrying doesn't have a name — no death, no disaster, just a quiet, persistent ache that something was always missing? In this episode of Joy Lab, we'll look at Gate Four of our grief series: What We Expected But Did Not Receive. Drawing from Francis Weller's The Wild Edge of Sorrow, we'll explore the grief that comes from never being fully welcomed, seen, or celebrated for exactly who you are — a loss so subtle it often masquerades as personal failure. This episode offers a deeply compassionate and scientifically grounded look at why so many of us feel vaguely unfulfilled and how we can actually do something about it. Spoiler: it starts with grieving what you were owed.

This episode is part of a 10-part series on grief. You can jump in here and circle back to Episode 248 when you're ready. 

 p.s. Find a Simple Joy practice for this episode right here at our blog.

 

About: The Joy Lab Podcast blends science and soul to help you cope better with stress, ease anxiety, and uplift mood. Join Dr. Henry Emmons and Dr. Aimee Prasek for practical, mindfulness-based tools and positive psychology strategies to build resilience and create lasting joy.

 

If you enjoyed this episode, please rate and review us wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts!

And... if you want to spread some joy and keep this podcast ad-free, then please join our mission by donating (Joy Lab is powered by the nonprofit Pathways North and your donations are tax-deductible).

 

Like and follow Joy Lab on Socials: 

Instagram

TikTok

Linkedin

Watch this episode on YouTube

 

Key moments:

[00:00:00] — Welcome & Series Context Henry and Aimee welcome listeners back to the Gates of Grief series within Joy Lab's Element of Savoring. Brief orientation for new listeners — no need to start at the beginning, though Episode 248 is waiting for you when you're ready.

[00:00:45] — Introducing Gate Four: What We Expected But Did Not Receive Unlike the more obvious losses of Gate One (everything we love, we will lose), this gate is about foundational things that should have been present but weren't. Francis Weller describes these as "things we may never realize we have lost because we weren't born into a village with full, joyous welcome of our gifts."

[00:02:00] — Love Is Not the Same as Welcome Aimee makes a critical and compassionate distinction:  love and welcome are not the same thing. True welcome says: you belong here exactly as you are. You don't have to earn your place. You don't have to be anything other than yourself. When that welcome is missing, it creates what Weller calls a diminished experience of who we are.

[00:03:00] — Longing to Belong and Longing to Be Longed For At the core of this gate is the deeply human drive for acceptance, connection, and support — not just nice-to-haves, but wired-in survival needs. When those aren't met, we carry unconscious disappointment, feelings of loneliness, and a persistent longing to belong.

[00:03:30] — Attachment Theory: Why This Gate Matters So Much Henry introduces attachment theory to help explain why this grief runs so deep. All primates are hardwired to form bonds with caregivers — not just for food and shelter, but for something far more nuanced: attunement. Attunement means being truly seen for who you are, not who your caregiver needs you to be.

[00:04:00] — Secure vs. Insecure Attachment When attuned care is consistent, we develop secure attachment: the world is safe, we matter, we can trust our experience. When it's inconsistent or absent, we adapt — we learn to be vigilant, to perform, to hide the parts of ourselves that don't meet approval. We learn, in short, that love is conditional.

[00:05:00] — It's Not About Blame — It's About Understanding the Cost Henry gently reframes this gate away from blame. Parents can love deeply and still miss attunement — distracted by their own pain, their work, their unmet needs. The point isn't to assign fault but to understand what was missing and what it cost us. Because when foundational welcome is absent, it doesn't just disappear — we carry it forward as a vague sense that something is off, that we're not quite enough.

[00:06:00] — The Invisible Grief Aimee highlights one of the most disorienting features of this gate: you might not even realize you're grieving. Unlike losing someone to death — where the loss has a clear object, others can see it, sympathy cards arrive — this grief is diffuse and unnamed. You feel vaguely unfulfilled, like you're always waiting for something just out of reach.

[00:06:30] — Connection to Savoring If you're carrying unconscious grief, a sense that something's missing that you can't quite name — it's hard to savor, to land fully in your life. This gate directly challenges our Element of Joy: savoring becomes difficult when unmet belonging is quietly running in the background.

[00:07:00] — When We Misread the Grief as Personal Failure Instead of naming this grief, many of us blame ourselves: we're a slacker, languishing, too sensitive, suffering from imposter syndrome — all framings that locate the problem inside us. But this gate insists: you are enough exactly as you are, and when that is not honored, that is the loss. The wound is the lack of welcome, not a deficiency in you.

[00:07:30] — Common Responses: Loneliness, Perfectionism, Shapeshifting Aimee names the predictable patterns we fall into when this grief goes unaddressed: closing up and feeling chronically lonely, chasing perfectionism or achievement to prove worthiness, or shapeshifting and masking to please others.

[00:08:00] — Belonging Actually Makes Us Better People A notable aside: creating a culture of acceptance and genuine belonging doesn't produce selfish, immoral people — it produces prosocial people. Research shows that when folks feel like they belong, they help others belong too. Doesn't that sound good right now?

[00:08:30] — This Gate Requires Cultivating Belonging You can't go back and change your childhood. But you can create new experiences in the present. This gate calls us to find or create the welcome and belonging we needed and still need.

[00:09:00] — Corrective Relational Experiences Henry picks up the thread: in attachment theory, corrective relational experiences are experiences that give us what we needed but didn't get the first time around. And here's the genuinely good news — it is never too late. This can happen at any age. When we find relationships — therapists, partners, friends, communities — where we are truly seen and accepted, it begins to rewire those old patterns. The nervous system finally gets the message: oh, this is what it feels like to be safe, to belong.

[00:10:00] — Emotional Backdraft: Why Healing Can Feel Worse Before It Feels Better Here's the paradox: we often resist corrective experiences when they show up because unconditional acceptance feels uncomfortable when we're not used to it. Henry names this as Emotional Backdraft — when we finally let our guard down, all the old feelings come flooding in and things can feel significantly worse before healing takes hold. But it is part of the healing. If the work feels uncomfortable, awkward, or even painful — take it as a positive sign. Something real is happening.

[00:11:30] — Practice One: Identify What You Needed But Didn't Receive Aimee offers a compassionate journaling and reflection practice with three core questions:

  • When I was a child, what did I long for?
  • What kind of welcome or support was missing?
  • What did I need that I didn't get?

As you reflect, let yourself grieve. These are losses. Name them and bless them on their way so they don't hold you captive.

[00:12:00] — Aimee's Personal Story: The Mission Trip and the Dogs Aimee shares a personal example from a childhood mission trip, where a leader told her she needed to care about people more than she cared about the dogs she was grieving for. It was a small moment that sent a big message: your way of caring is wrong. Years later, she can name it: that was bad advice, and that diminishment of her natural empathy was a real loss worth grieving.

[00:13:30] — Grieving for Those Who Couldn't Give It Aimee offers a compassionate reframe: in nearly every case, the people who failed to welcome you fully didn't have it to give. They likely carried the same ache. This is not a blame exercise — it's a grieving practice. And it can be emotionally intense, so give yourself care, support, and permission to do it in bits.

[00:14:30] — Practice Two: Internal Family Systems (IFS) and Self Energy Henry introduces IFS as a practical tool for this gate. The practice: access self energy — the wise, compassionate observing core that exists in all of us — and from that place, turn toward the parts of yourself that carry these old wounds with genuine curiosity, not a fixing agenda. Ask: What does this part of me need right now? Then listen. Not for what you think you should need — for what actually comes up.

That younger part might need to hear:

  • I'm here now. I'm not going anywhere.
  • You didn't do anything wrong. You deserve better.
  • Or simply to be held in your awareness without anything being fixed.

[00:16:00] — Bring It Into Relationship This is important: you do need to bring it into relationship with others. Not because you're broken, but because we are wired for connection. That's how we heal — in relationship. Find your people. The ones who can hold space for all of you, including the parts that didn't get what they needed. And when you find them — stay.

[00:17:00] — Practice Letting Yourself Be Seen Practice staying. Practice believing — even just a little — that you truly do belong. And if you feel hesitancy or awkwardness when accepting welcome, give yourself credit. That's not failure — that's Emotional Backdraft, which means you're opening up. Something is moving through you. That is a very good sign.

[00:17:30] — Brené Brown on Leaning Into Being Seen Dr. Brené Brown's work gets a nod here: "lean into the discomfort of being truly seen." As we savor and stay and savor again, we build a new story of acceptance and belonging — and that opens the gate to so much more. More love. More connection. More joy.

[00:18:00] — What's Next: Gate Five — Ancestral Grief Next episode, Aimee and Henry explore the pain we carry from those who came before us and how to tend to generational sorrow.

[00:19:00] — Closing Quote: Mirabai Starr "Something magical happens when we bear witness to each other in grief. Something alchemical. It transmutes the lead of our devastation into the gold of connection. Our own compassion is activated. Our souls are soothed. The narrow circle of our private pain expands and we recognize that we belong to each other. We take our rightful place in the web of interbeing and find refuge." — Mirabai Starr

 

Sources and Notes for this full grief series:

 

Please remember that this content is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to provide medical advice and is not a replacement for advice and treatment from a medical professional. Please consult your doctor or other qualified health professional before beginning any diet change, supplement, or lifestyle program.

Please see our terms for more information.

If you or someone you know is struggling or in crisis, help is available. Call the NAMI HelpLine: 1-800-950-6264 available Monday through Friday, 10 a.m. – 10 p.m., ET. OR text "HelpLine" to 62640 or email NAMI at [email protected]. Visit NAMI for more. You can also call or text SAMHSA at 988 or chat 988lifeline.org.